Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Winston G Adams's avatar

First: your interview on NTV about the CFs MOU: Both you and Gabe seem much aligned that the MOU should be declared dead. Gabe said Jennifer should be out, and you said the same in the past, not sure if you still feel that way? And Gabe thinks Kennedy should should be out (I agree) but

do understand that he can be a fierce advocate for his client, BUT comes with considerable baggage, as to fiercely defending MFs on many fronts.

The recent news that PQ doesn't need that present MOU, that it is much cheaper for them to add 10OOO Mw of Wind to replace 5400 Mw of CFs power: There is much ignorance of the value of wind: At 40% average capacity it gives only 4000 MW on average. With bouts of a few days with no wind, including during winter cold snaps. that can be near ZERO wind energy. Wind must be intergrated with conserving water, so more hydro power can be ramped up during those cold snaps.

The Smallwood Reservior is the LARGEST in the world (based on MW production, due to its 1000 ft drop in elevation to the turbines).

So HQ wind NEEDS CFs water storage even for wind.

An alternate, inferior one, for HQ is to add the cost of massive battery storage in place of CFs water storage, with added higher O&M costs, equipment replacement costs;

For 12 hrs storage that HQ option is 3 TIMES more expensive, and for 24 hrs, its 4 TIMES more expensive.

Where if the NH expertise on the value/ cost/ overall benefit of wind (whether for the island or Labrador or PQ? It is Jennifer Williams? Who with NL can speak with expertise on wind ? Name please?

The HQ wind alternative can have value, but is a BIG BLUFF as to a super low cost replacement for CFs.

For 15 years there has been essentially silence, locally, on the capability/ benefit of wind for the island or Labrador, or HQ, from engineers / officials here. As Gabe said, we need to hire real experts here for true assessment of this major asset, and not be bluffed by HQ or PQ politicians.

1 more comment...

No posts

Ready for more?